Senator Michael Duffy, as he is styled in Hansard, gave his maiden speech in the Senate yesterday and used the occasion to praise the prime minister and then please the prime minister with some shots at Newfoundland and Labrador Premier Danny Williams and PEI Premier Robert Ghiz He also forced some debate on the use of BlackBerrys in the Senate. Some highlights:
“…one cannot be a successful leader without sound political judgment and the courage to make tough decisions despite determined opposition.
I am here to tell honourable senators today — this is where the hard part begins — Stephen Harper has both that judgment and that courage. He has an economic plan that I believe is right for these troubled times. Despite the bleating of a few, this economic action plan does more for more people in more parts of Canada than any budget in my memory.
Duffy's BlackBerry then buzzed and, true to form, he stopped what he was saying, read it, and then immediately worked it in to his speech:
My BlackBerry just went off with a message from my staff person in Prince Edward Island, who reminds me, having read this text in advance, not to forget how important small business is to P.E.I. Sixty per cent of all our economic activity is small business.
Shortly after that, he took on Williams and Ghiz:
Honourable senators, I urge you to ignore the nattering nabobs of negativism on the East Coast, particularly the Premier of Newfoundland and Labrador, who, I believe, does not do Newfoundlanders and Labradorians any favours by the kind of personal attacks he has made over the last couple of years; nor by his remarks that paint Newfoundlanders, who are the among the most generous, caring and committed Canadians, as greedy and selfish. Those remarks are unworthy of the great people of Newfoundland and Labrador.
Honourable senators, I was disappointed to see that our dynamic young Premier in Prince Edward Island, Robert Ghiz, has climbed into bed with the Premier of Newfoundland and Labrador, and honourable senators know what a grotesque scene that is. Do honourable senators know what happens when two politicians climb into bed together? One of them comes out on top and I am afraid that when one is in bed with Danny Williams he will come out on top and I would hate to see where that will leave P.E.I. in the end . .
Senator Joan Fraser, who, like Duffy, was a journalist — she was the editor of The Montreal Gazette — prior to her appointment quickly follows and has some bad news for the new senator from Prince Edward Island:
We are always glad to see new senators, particularly when they come from the world's greatest craft.
The honourable senator obviously has many friends in his caucus, and I am sure they have all been helping, supporting and instructing him. However, I wonder whether any of them have yet drawn to his attention a Speaker's ruling that suggests that BlackBerrys are not okay in the Senate chamber.
But, happily for Duffy and other Blackberry-addicted Senators, the Senate rules have been slightly modified, as the Speaker of the Senate, Noel Kinsella, rules:
Senator Duffy: It was brought to my attention that devices that make noise are not allowed in the chamber. I did not realize that BlackBerrys are banned.
The Hon. the Speaker: As reference has been made to the Rules of the Senate, and as it is the responsibility of the Speaker to maintain order and ensure that the rules are followed, I must say that the Honourable Senator Duffy is absolutely correct. Rule 19(4) states that “No person, nor any Senator, shall bring any electronic device which produces any sound . . .” into the chamber.
Hon. Joseph A. Day: It is my understanding that BlackBerrys indirectly make a sound in this chamber by interfering with our sound system. If the Speaker is ruling that it is okay to bring BlackBerrys into the chamber if they are on vibration mode, that is okay, but I do not think that is what we understood to be the situation
The Hon. the Speaker: They did interfere with our older loudspeaker sound system, but we modified the system in the chamber so that they no longer interfere. That is the technical advice we received.
The rule is that if a device makes a noise, it is not allowed in the chamber.