MPs BlackBerry rules: Not for "the private interests of a Member or a Member's immediate family"

When you are elected to the House of Commons, you are handed a document called The Members' Manual of Allowance and Services. This document is published by The Speakers Office of the House of Commons and the content and policies that are contained in it are approved by what's known as the Board of Internal Economy, a committee of MPs from all parties who meet in secret every couple of weeks to discuss the financial matters of the House of Common and its general administration. This is the manual that sets out the ground rules for setting up and running an MPs office.

So far as I can tell, the Members Manual of Allowance and Services is not available on the Internet that most Canadians can use but is available on the Parliamentary intranet to which computers in almost every office on the Parliamentary Precinct are connected. As our bureau is not within the Parliamentary Precinct (but is two blocks away) and therefore is not on the Parliamentary intranet, my colleague, Global National producer Pam McKenzie, asked the Speakers Office last week for a copy of that manual, and was provided with one, after revelations emerged that then Minister of State for Status of Women Helena Guergis had provided her spouse, former Edmonton MP Rahim Jaffer, with one of the four BlackBerry wireless devices that all MPs are authorized to procure and use for the administration of their MPs office. Each BlackBerry comes with a Parliamentary e-mail account tied to the MPs office.

Here are the relevant excerpts from the Members' Manual has to say about the use and care of wireless devices that will be paid for by the House of Commons and, by extension, all taxpayers (I have provided the emphasis):

1. Introduction

Members are provided with operating funds, office premises in the Parliamentary Precinct and goods and services to be used to carry out their parliamentary functions (see definition below)

2. Furniture, Computer, Equipment, and Supplies

Members are provided with standard furniture, equipment and supplies based on a scale of entitlement approved by the Board of Internal Economy, to support the operation of their Ottawa office . . ,

Wireless Devices: Members are provided with up to four (4) wireless devices, including three (3) voice plans, one (1) data plan, applicable monthly fees, air time, long-distance charges, and features such as voice mail, access fees and 911 services. Eligible devices include cell phones, pagers and Personal Digital Assistants (PDA) and must be procured by Telecommunications Services. .

Definitions

Parliamentary Functions

Duties and activities related to the position of Member of the House of Commons wherever performed and include public and official business, and partisan matters, but do not include the private business interests of a Member or a Member's immediate family. (reference: By-law 101)

Why is all this important?
It seems probable — indeed, highly likely — that the use by Jaffer of the e-mail account and wireless device by a sitting MP — and a minister, no less — is connected to the series of events the led to Prime Minister Stephen Harper calling in the cops on Guergis. E-mail and PIN traffic to and from each BlackBerry is almost certainly archived and stored by the administrators of the House of Commons information technology and telecommunications services. The admission Thursday by Guergis' spokesman that Jaffer had the use of one of her BlackBerrys — and her office's defence of the practice by noting that everybody does it — may have have initially worried the PMO that this practice was something Parliament's ethics commissioner ought to look into. But then, presumably, someone connected with the PMO asked to review some of the correspondence that came through the account associated with Jaffer and that may have triggered the heightened concerns that led to the belief that, in addition to ethics commissioner, the police ought to be investigating.

UPDATE: Anonymous commenter below claims PINs are not archived and that an MP would turn over e-mail only in response to a search warrant or an order from the Speaker. I am almost certain that the folks who run parl.gc.ca, just like any big corporation in Canada, archive all communications, including e-mail and PINs, involving any device they own and for which they are, ultimately, legally responsible. My tech sources on that are pretty solid though, as always, an on-the-record source will always change my mind. On the second point, that MPs must divulge e-mail only in extraordinary situations, I'm keen to see if someone would step up to substantiate that important point. Please e-mail me if you can.

In his own words: Harper on Guergis

Yesterday, Prime Minister Stephen Harper did what no prime minister has done in nearly 25 years: He called the cops on one of his own cabinet ministers. After doing so, he held a brief “media availability” in the foyer of the House of Comons where he read a statement and answered a few questions. Here is my transcript of the English-language part of those proceedings (my written French leaving much to be desired):

Harper: Last night, my office became aware of serious allegations regarding the conduct of the Honourable Helena Guergis. These allegations relate to the conduct of Ms. Guergis and do not involve any other minister, MP, senator or federal government employee. I've referred the allegations to the Conflict of Interest and Ethics Commissioner and to the RCMP. Under the circumstances, I will not comment on them further.

Ms. Guergis offered her resignation from the ministry and I accepted it. Pending a resolution, she will sit outside of the Conservative Party caucus. In the meantime, I have asked the Honourable Rona Ambrose to assume additional responsibility for the Status of Women portfolio.

Dimitri Soudas, Press Secretary to the prime minister: We'll start with Craig Oliver, CTV.

Oliver: Prime Minister, is there any evidence at all that Ms. Guergis might have communicated with members of your government in an effort to further her husband's business interests?

Harper: I have no allegations that would pertain to any other minister, any member of parliament, any other senator or any employee of the Government of Canada.

Soudas: On va continuer avec Daniel Thibault, Radio-Canada.

[Thibault asks Harper, in French, if the allegations which the prime minister heard about the night before had anything to do with Guergis' husband Rahim Jaffer. The prime minister responds first in French and then says…)

Harper: Just let me answer that in English as well. I'm not going to answer questions about what other individuals these allegations may touch upon. Mr. Jaffer is a private citizen. I just do want to say in response to yesterday's story, I think my office said this already but let me repeat it, any suggestion that Mr. Jaffer has had an open door to my office is false.

Soudas: Continue with David Akin, Canwest. We'll continue with David Akin, Canwest. Thank you, Jennifer.

Akin: Prime Minister, I just wondered, when you called the Oliphant inquiry, one of your motives you said at the time was because you were concerned about the integrity of the Prime Minister's Office and I wonder today as well if you have any concerns about the integrity of the Prime Minister's Office given what we know and if this is the reason for your actions today.

Harper: No, not at all. The information we've received did not indicate any such thing. I think you know our views, how we conduct ourselves are clear. We have clear rules. We expect people to follow them. And, David, if they don't, we take appropriate action. And I have no reason to believe anybody on my staff has acted improperly.

Soudas: Nous avons temps pour une dernière question. Hugo de Grandpré, La Presse.

[De Grandpré then asks in French if Ms. Guergis did not resign but was, in fact, fired. Harper responding in French says that, given the circumstances, it's pretty much one and the same.]

Jennifer Ditchburn, The Canadian Press: Mr. Harper, are you disappointed in Ms. Guergis?

Harper: Let me just very quickly answer that even though you're not on a list. Look, of course we're – of course I'm disappointed with this. You know I hope – of course we all hope in these circumstances things will resolve themselves in a way that's satisfactory to everybody but, no, I'm very disappointed. It's a very sad day. But, you know, in this business you get the brick bats as well as the bouquets so when you confront these things, you deal with them and that's what we've done.

Soudas: Thank you very much, everybody. Merci beaucoup. Thank you.

Best films about the newspaper and TV news biz?

In New York City, this month, an independent movie house is running a series its calling The Newspaper Picture. It looks like a great idea. The series leads off this weekend with Ace In The Hole , the 1951 film from ace director Billy Wilder, and closes with Alan J. Pakula’s classic All the President’s Men. It also includes His Girl Friday (1940), a favourite of one Mr. A. Coyne of Maclean’s magazine and mine, which you may have seen as The Front Page on stage or in the 1931 film or the 1974 version with Jack Lemmon and Walter Matthau.

A.O. Scott, the film critic, writes about the series in The New York Times, in a piece with the appropriate headline, “The Fearless Press, and other legends”:

“Remember newspapers? Neither do I, to tell you the truth, even though I’ve been working at this one for more than 10 years. But you have to go back a lot further— nearly half a century — to sample the sights, sounds and smells that still evoke the quintessence of print journalism in all its inky, hectic glory.

Or you could go to Film Forum, where a 43-movie month-long series called The Newspaper Picture opens on Friday … The program is a crackerjack history lesson and also, perhaps, a valediction. Not a day goes by that we don’t read something — a tweet, a blog, maybe even a column — proclaiming the death of newspapers, either to mourn or to dance on the grave. And even if those old newsprint creatures survive, say by migrating to the magic land of the iPad, they sure ain’t what they used to be. Where are the crusty editors and fast-talking girl reporters of yesteryear? I’m peeking over the cubicle wall, and all I see are Web producers and videographers.”

Continue reading Best films about the newspaper and TV news biz?

Helena Guergis; a B.C. political scandal, and stormy Saskatchewa: Saturday's A1 headlines and Parliamentary daybook

Calgary Herald front page The trials of Helena Guergus; B.C.'s political scandal; and stormy Saskatchewan: Listen to my two -minute audio roundup of what's on the front pages of the country's newspapers plus highlights from Saturday's Parliamentary daybook by clicking on the link below. Listen!

You can also get these audio summaries automatically every day via podcast from iTunes or via an RSS feed by subscribing to my AudioBoo stream. Both the iTunes link and the RSS link are at my profile at AudioBoo.fm. Lookin the top right corner of the “Boos” box.

Guergis calls allegations "baseless, unfounded" as Harper calls in the cops

kawempe.jpg

Several rather remarkable developments today on the Helena Guergis story …

Prime Minister Stephen Harper called in the RCMP Friday on one of his own cabinet ministers, Helena Guergis, kicking her out of cabinet and the Conservative caucus.

Guergis said she's the victim of “baseless allegations and unfounded assertions.”

In the resignation letter she submitted to Harper, a copy of which was obtained by Canwest News Service, Guergis said: “I take responsibility for any errors I may have made, but at no time did I compromise my oath as a Member of the Privy Council.

“It has become apparent through baseless allegations and unfounded assertions made about my family that I need to step aside to allow for the good work of our government to continue serving Canadians,” she wrote.

Harper would not say why he asked the RCMP and Parliament's conflict of interest commissioner to investigate Guergis' activities other than to say he was prompted to act after his office learned of “some serious allegations regarding the conduct” of Guergis, who was the minister of state for the status of women.

Though Guergis technically resigned her position, Harper, at a Parliament Hill news conference, made it clear she had little choice in the matter . . .

Read the rest of the story.

[The picture to the right is one I took in 2007 in the Kawempe slum in Kampala, Uganda while covering Prime Minister Stephen Harper's attendance at the 2007 Commonwealth Summit. Guergis, in red, was then the secretary of state for foreign affairs and Rahim Jaffer, to her left, was then an Edmonton MP (and, at the time, her fiance).]

Vimy

vimymorn.jpg

The absolute best part of my job is that every now and again, you pull a dream assignment. That was the case in April, 2007 when I was assigned to travel with the Prime Minister of Canada for the ceremonies at Vimy Ridge, France marking the 90th anniversary of the famous First World War battle. On that Easter Sunday in 2007, the travelling media were virtually alone on the ridge, ahead of the thousands who would be there that afternoon, as the sun came up. Every one of us, including me, snapped as many pictures of this scene as we could. Of course, it was nothing like that 90 years earlier. There was no dawn on April 9, 1917, just terrible, wet, cold weather and mud that could swallow horses.

I've got some more pics from this assignment at my Facebook page.

Harper asks RCMP to investigate his own minister

journal.jpg

Prime Minister Stephen Harper's statement, issued about an hour ago:

“Last night my office became aware of serious allegations regarding the conduct of the Honourable Helena Guergis. These allegations relate to the conduct of Ms. Guergis and do not involve any other Ministers, MPs, Senators or federal government employees.

“I have referred the allegations to the Conflict of Interest and Ethics Commissioner and to the RCMP. Under the circumstances, I will not comment on them further.

“Ms. Guergis offered her resignation from the Ministry, and I accepted it. Pending a resolution, she will sit outside of the Conservative Party Caucus. I have asked the Honourable Rona Ambrose to assume additional responsibility for the Status of Women portfolio.”

Canada's stuck with a terrorist; the Vatican's silence; and death in the oilpatch: Friday's A1 headlines and Parliamentary daybook

Canada stuck with terrorist; the Vatican silences a scandal; death in the oilpatch and  Listen to my four -minute audio roundup of what's on the front pages of the country's newspapers plus highlights from Friday's Parliamentary daybook by clicking on the link below.

Listen!

You can also get these audio summaries automatically every day via podcast from iTunes or via an RSS feed by subscribing to my AudioBoo stream. Both the iTunes link and the RSS link are at my profile at AudioBoo.fm. Lookin the top right corner of the "Boos" box.

Tags: , , , , ,

'Delighted' to leave Canadian custoy for an Afghan jail: The odd testimony of a Canadian sergeant

Through much of 2007, Canadian Forces military police officer Sgt. Carol Utton personally witnessed and participated in the transfer of dozens of suspected Taliban insurgents from the Canadian base at Kandahar Airfield in Afghanistan to Afghan authorities. The detainees would be taken to an Afghan-run prison where — I'm sure you've heard by now — we have now been told by senior Canadian diplomats testifying before a House of Commons committee [and, no, that's not a link to Richard Colvin but to another, even more senior, diplomat] that torture of those prisoners was widespread and routine at that time.

And yet — as Sgt. Utton, a military police office, testified this week in Ottawa before the Military Police Complaints Commission:

… once the Afghans had the detainee, Utton and other military police had no responsibility — or even interest — in the welfare of their former prisoners. She testified that, so far as she was aware, there was never any order or training for military police to take an interest in or to inspect conditions in Afghan prisons.

Indeed, military police had little cause for concern because the about-to-be transferred detainees themselves appeared to look forward to being in Afghan custody.

“Some of them seemed quite delighted,” Utton said in response to questioning by commission counsel Ron Lunau.

In fact, she described to the commission how upset one detainee was when Afghan authorities refused to take him and he was forced to stay in Canadian custody.

“The detainee had suffered severe medical complications after his IED exploded on him and he was quite injured by the time the transfer was to be made,” Utton said. “The (Afghans) were going to refuse because (Canadian media reports) said that the (Afghan) jail is filthy and the (Afghans) did not want to be blamed for anything that might happen to this detainee. And it took a lot of convincing that he was medically fit to be transferred. And the (Afghans) did take him at the time, but they had reservations.”

[Read the rest of the story ..]

Tags: , ,

Canada's rosy economic forecast; drug store battle and the back story on Rahim Jaffer: Thursday's A1 headlines and Parliamentary daybook

Canada's rosy economic forecast; drug store battle and a top investigative reporter looks into the back story on Rahim Jaffer's arrest;  Listen to my four -minute audio roundup of what's on the front pages of the country's newspapers plus highlights from Thursday's Parliamentary daybook by clicking on the link below.

Listen!

You can also get these audio summaries automatically every day via podcast from iTunes or via an RSS feed by subscribing to my AudioBoo stream. Both the iTunes link and the RSS link are at my profile at AudioBoo.fm. Lookin the top right corner of the "Boos" box.

Tags: , , , , ,