Iggy vs Harper: Day one of the rest of the Michael Ignatieff's (political) life

A few minutes before Question Period got underway in the House of Commons today, as MPs were arriving and settling into their seats, Prime Minister Stephen Harper walked across the green-carpeted aisle that divides the House of Commons and, warmly smiling, reached out to shake Michael Ignatieff's hand, presumably to congratulate him on the results of the Liberal convention over the weekend in Vancouver at which Iggy officially became the Leader of the Opposition. BQ Leader Gilles Duceppe and Transport Minister John Baird also walked over to shake Iggy's hand.

And then, it was game on. Here's the play-by-play:

Mr. Michael Ignatieff (Leader of the Opposition, Lib.): Mr. Speaker, employment insurance is not working in this country and there are some key issues that need to be fixed: access, benefit levels, maternity leave, fairness across regions and the status of the self-employed. Will the Prime Minister commit to launching an independent examination of these issues and present concrete proposals for reform before the House rises in June?

Right Hon. Stephen Harper (Prime Minister, CPC): Mr. Speaker, as the leader of the Liberal Party should know, Canada has a very generous system of employment insurance that was, in fact, enhanced in the most recent economic action plan of this government. I am perplexed by the sudden interest of the Liberal Party in NDP employment insurance policy. I guess the reason to borrow this is to create a diversion from the reaffirmation at the Liberal convention of the carbon tax. It is not any better an idea the second time around.

Ignatieff: Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister believes in magic thinking. He believes that if one repeats a falsehood constantly, it becomes true. It does not. It remains a falsehood. On employment insurance, there is one problem that can be fixed right now. There are 58 standards of eligibility for EI across the country. That makes eligibility depend on where one lives and that is wrong. Will the Prime Minister commit to an immediate 360 hour national standard of eligibility for employment insurance while this crisis lasts?

Harper: Mr. Speaker, once again, the leader of the Liberal Party will know that that is a long-time policy of the New Democratic Party, not of the Liberal Party. When we are talking about saying things that are true, I am only quoting the leader of the Liberal Party himself, who has said repeatedly that he wants to “raise taxes”. I know he is being honest. He is just honestly wrong.

Ignatieff: Mr. Speaker, for a prime minister who levied a punitive tax on income trusts, that is really something. Dès aujourd'hui, le premier ministre peut venir en aide aux milliers de chômeurs qui ne sont pas éligibles pour l'assurance-emploi en ce moment. Pourquoi ne s'engage-t-il pas immédiatement à créer un seuil national d'éligibilité de 360 heures?

Harper: Monsieur le Président, ce parti a demandé au Parti libéral de donner ses suggestions pour le Plan d'action économique en janvier. Nous n'avons pas reçu de suggestion. Au lieu de cela, nous avons bonifié les prestations d'assurance-emploi. Let me just go back to this issue of the tax fairness package, which was a big net tax cut to Canadians, brought down business tax rates across the board and for the first time in history brought in income splitting for the pensioners of this country. That party voted against it. This party voted for it because we believe in cutting taxes.

Here's my story on today in QP.

Help: Need Google contextual menu for Mac OS X

Hello geeks — need your help!

I want a contextual menu plug-in for Mac OS X that will let me right click on any highlighted text in any application — not just browsers or Apple apps — and then search Google on the highlighted text, returning the results of that search in a Firefox window. Apple's “Services” will let me do that but will only let me return Google Search results in Safari. And yes, I've told Safari that “Firefox” is my default browser. Doesn't matter. Firefox is a “carbon app” and Safari is a “cocoa” app. As a result they take advantage of Apple's “Services” differently.

Maybe you know of a quick little Apple Script that will do the same thing?

Post results below or e-mail me. thanks!

Canada gets Obama's attention

And apparently, we've got his attention because we're so darn boring! But, hey, that's OK with me. Nothing wrong with being boring. Here's an excerpt of an interview President Obama gave to David Leonhardt, the economics columist for The New York Times. The interview was published today in The New York Times Magazine:

THE PRESIDENT: You know, I’ve looked at the evidence so far that indicates that other countries that have not seen some of the problems in their financial markets that we have nevertheless don’t separate between investment banks and commercial banks, for example. They have a “supermarket” model that they’ve got strong regulation of.

Like Canada?

THE PRESIDENT: Canada being a good example. And they’ve actually done a good job in managing through what was a pretty risky period in the financial markets. (Akin's note: A footnote in the Leonhardt article notes that Canada's banks now rank in the top 50 but a better footnote would have been to note that not a single Canadian bank has collapsed, is in danger of collapsing, or has required a penny in government bailouts or equity. Some U.S. banks and banks in most of our G7 peers have required government money to avoid collapse.)

So — that doesn’t mean that, for example, an insurance company like A.I.G. grafting a hedge fund on top of it is something that is optimal. Even with the best regulators, if you start having so much differentiation of functions and products within a single company, a single institution, a conglomerate, essentially, things could potentially slip through the cracks. And people just don’t know what they’re getting into. I mean, I guarantee you that the average A.I.G. insurance policyholder had no idea that this stuff was going on. And in that sense I think you can make an argument that there may be a breaking point in which functions are so different that you don’t want a single company doing everything.

But when it comes to something like investment banking versus commercial banking, the experience in a country like Canada would indicate that good, strong regulation that focuses less on the legal form of the institution and more on the functions that they’re carrying out is probably the right approach to take.

Ottawa puts millions into PEI, NS small craft harbours

The Small Craft Harbours Program is a $100-million-a-year fund the federal Department of Fisheries and Oceans manages to ” to accelerate harbour repair and maintenance, as well as undertake dredging projects.” But, as with just about every penny the federal government spends nowadays, any expenditures out of this fund are sold as “Canada's Economic Action Plan.” Fair enough. To the fishers and others who use these harbours, it most likely doesn't matter what you call it, so long as the work gets done. On the weekend, two regional ministers announced more than $50 million worth of projects for PEI and Nova Scotia.

Over the weekend, Fisheries Minister Gail Shea (left) announced $13.9 million worth of projects in her native PEI and, next door in Nova Scotia, Defence Minister Peter MacKay put his name on a fisheries press release to make sure he gets a little political credit for the $40.2 million Shea's department will spend fixing up harbours in his province.

Here's the Nova Scotia projects:

  • Major harbour development projects currently underway will be accelerated this year at Arisaig, Margaree, Newellton, Pictou Landing and West Head. New major projects will be starting at Canso, Centreville, Dennis Point, Falls Point, Lower East Pubnico, Lower Sandy Point, and Saulnierville. Planning for future major projects will take place at Caribou Ferry, Cheticamp, Havre Boucher, Louisbourg, Murphys Pond, Neils Harbour, Port Bickerton East and Wedge Point.
  • Wharf repairs and improvements are planned for Abbots Harbour, Bush Island, Caribou Ferry, Cribbons Point, Delaps Cove, Fox Point, Halls Harbour, Hampton, Indian Point, Ingomar, Jones Harbour, Little River (Digby County), Lower Prospect, Lower Wedgeport, Mabou, Marie Joseph, Meteghan, Mill Cove, Neils Harbour, Owls Head, Port Morien, Shag Harbour, Skinners Cove, Sonora, Toney River, Wallace, West Green Harbour, West Head and Westport.
  • Dredging work is scheduled for Dennis Point, Dingwall, Pleasant Bay, Little River Harbour, Port Morien, Skinners Cove and Toney River.
  • Breakwater construction and repairs will take place at Baileys Brook, Bay St. Lawrence, Cripple Creek, Ingonish Ferry, Margaree, Pleasant Bay and Port La Tour.
  • The construction and repair of launching ramps will be undertaken at Battery Point, Bay St. Lawrence, Big Bras d'Or, Canso, Central Port Mouton, Little Liscomb, Margaree, Owls Head, Peggys Cove, Pictou Landing and West Berlin.
  • Electrical service improvements will be carried out at Cheticamp and Bay St. Lawrence.

And here's the PEI projects:

  • Major harbour development work is well underway at Alberton while new major harbour projects will be starting at Tignish and West Point. Planning work for future large, harbour development projects will be starting at Machons Point and Nine Mile Creek.
  • Wharf repair and reconstruction projects are slated for Bay Fortune, Beach Point, Covehead, Georgetown, Graham Pond, Howards Cove, Launching Pond, McAuleys Shore, Montague, Murray River, Naufrage, New London, Miminegash, North Rustico, Red Head, Seacow Pond, Skinners Pond, Tracadie and Wood Islands.
  • Dredging is scheduled for Covehead, Malpeque, Miminegash, Naufrage, North Lake, Skinners Pond, Tracadie and Victoria.
  • Breakwater reconstruction at Seacow Pond will protect harbour facilities while armourstone will be installed on the west entrance breakwater at Naufrage. Shore protection is planned for Miminegash while the slipway at Graham Pond will be reconstructed.

Quickly glancing through the location of these projects, it seems to me that money is being spent in ridings held by government MPs (Tignish and West Point in Shea's riding, Pictou Landing and Caribou Ferry in MacKay's riding) as much as it's being spent on wharves held by Liberal MPs – Cheticamp and Louisbourg in NS and Murray River and Montague in PEI, for example — but if you think these projects have a partisan slant to them, I'm all ears.

Best of April 2009

This blog saw more than 115,000 unique visits in April. Thanks all for dropping by. And if there's something you're particularly interested in seeing, feel free to drop me a line. All my contact info is always at www.davidakin.com.

I should note that a post that's nearly 5 years old is in the top 10.

In the meantime, here's the most clicked-upon posts from April (feel free to use the handy-dandy search box for those without a hyperlink) with the time and date they originally appeared at David Akin's On The Hill:

  1. So tell me again: Why did we spend $3.4-billion on these things? Fri 23 May 2008 10:08 AM EDT
  2. Bisphenol A: We hardly knew you … Sun 27 Apr 2008 10:52 PM EDT
  3. The Onion gets it right — eight years early Mon 19 Jan 2009 10:30 PM EST
  4. Conservatives feuding in eastern Alberta? Mon 06 Apr 2009 10:26 PM EDT
  5. New syntax for Twitter #ottawaspends Tue 07 Apr 2009 01:03 PM EDT
  6. The only leader to stand up to Harper … Thu 29 Jan 2009 12:05 PM EST
  7. Duelling perspectives on science funding Tue 07 Apr 2009 10:24 AM EDT
  8. We're all Keynesians now – except in Alberta Wed 08 Apr 2009 04:52 PM EDT
  9. Fun with iTunes or Bob Willis is NOT Lionel Richie Wed 10 Sep 2008 11:04 PM EDT
  10. Wheat Board politics: Ritz vs Goodale Mon 09 Jun 2008 12:50 PM EDT
  11. Who pays for this blog? Some disclaimers Fri 13 Aug 2004 08:09 AM EDT
  12. Shea gets grilled on anti-Liberal press releases Sat 04 Apr 2009 01:07 PM EDT
  13. Liberals publish roadmap to rebuild party Thu 16 Apr 2009 12:41 PM EDT
  14. The size of the inaugural crowd: A journalist's dilemma Sun 18 Jan 2009 10:20 AM EST
  15. Hey! I'm gonna be on Google! Thu 16 Apr 2009 04:03 PM EDT
  16. When it comes to press relations, do you like Obama or Harper? Fri 20 Feb 2009 09:10 PM EST
  17. BBC's Economics Editor gushes about Canada Wed 01 Apr 2009 12:04 PM EDT
  18. Experts say: Wake up Canada – you're about to lose control of over Canada's waterways Mon 23 Feb 2009 07:43 PM EST
  19. Harper holds conference call with reporters: (Mostly) U.S. Reporters Mon 20 Apr 2009 05:41 PM EDT
  20. The numbers are out on third-party election advertising Fri 27 Feb 2009 04:27 PM EST

The NDP on fundraising and party finances – First quarter was an odd quarter

200905022141.jpg

It is Brad Lavigne's first day in his new job as national director of the New Democratic Party of Canada and he spent part of it explaining what, on the face of it, might look to be disappointing party fundraising results for the first quarter of 2009. Those numbers, as well as the numbers for every federal party, were released today by Elections Canada.

For the first three months of the year, the federal New Democrats raised $595,611 from about 10,000 contributors.

That compares to $1.75 million raised in the fourth quarter of 2008 and $1.12 million raised in the same quarter a year ago.

“We knew this in advance and this is a short-term phenomenon,” Lavigne told me. “We are on pace to pay off our debt — a small debt fro the election and we are healthy enough to run an election campaign at any given moment.”

The numbers looked soft, Lavigne said, because the federal party stayed on the sidelines for most of the quarter in some of its most important regions of the country.

In B.C. and Nova Scotia, where provincial wings of the party are either fighting or about to fight a provincial election, the federal fundraisers stayed out of the way so that the provincial parties could fill up their war chests. In Ontario and in Saskatchewan, provincial parties were busy choosing a new leader, a process which taxes the financial and volunteer resources for the New Democrat base. Recognizing that, the federal party did not do any aggressive fundraising there.

“Added to all this is a recession,” Lavigne said. “The recession is hurting. There's no doubt about that.”

And, just as the economy is expected to show strong growth towards the back half of this year, Lavigne said he expects his party's fundraising campaign to show some improvement in the third and fourth quarters of 2009.

Tories continue to dominate fundraising but Liberals improve

In the first quarter of this year, 69,451 Canadians contributed a total of $7.1 million to a federal political party.

Both those numbers were down significantly compared to the fourth quarter of 2008, a quarter which saw political tension in Ottawa raised to new heights as a Stephane Dion-led coalition threatened to unseat Stephen Harper's Conservatives.

Still, when compared to the first three months of 2008, overall political financial activity was off but by much less. Year-over-year contributions fell by 0.6 per cent and the overall number of contributors fell by about five per cent.

But there were some substantial changes so far as individual parties go.

Though the Conservative Party is absolutely dominant — continuing to raise more money than all other parties combined from more contributors than all other parties combained — the Liberals appear to be finally seeing some results in fundraising efforts that have trailed all other parties while the NDP has show a sharp drop.

More than 39,000 Canadians kicked in a combined $4.36 million dollars to the Conservatives in the last quarter, a drop of 31 per cent from the previous quarter and a drop of 12 per cent from the same quarter a year ago.

And while the Liberal haul of $1.83 million in the first quarter of this year was down about 20 per cent compared to the last quarter, it was more than double or up 117% compared to the same period last year. More than 15,000 people cut a cheque to the Liberal. Just two years ago, in the first quarter of 2007, fewer than 4,400 Canadians were contributing to that party.

Meanwhile, the NDP's financial haul at just $595,611 dropped by 47 per cent year-over-year and 66 per cent quarter-over-quarter. There were just over 10,000 Canadians contributing to the NDP.

The Green Party raised $211,269 from 2,868 people in the quarter, about the same as the same period last year, but that was down 61 per cent from the last quarter.

The Bloc Quebecois raised $122,842 from 1,600 people, down 35 per cent quarter-over-quarter but up substantially from the $37,006 it raised from 463 people in the first quarter last year.

Sheryl King to head up Merrill's Canadian economics shop

Banc of America Securities-Merrill Lynch just announced that Sheryl King will succeed David Wolf as the Toronto-based head of Canada Econimics and Investment Strategy. Wolf left Merrill last month to take a position as a senior advisor at the Bank of Canada.

King, a Canadian, had been working as senior U.S. economist at Merrill. Before that she was in economics department at TD Bank.

There is only one other woman heading up a Canadian economics shop. That would be BMO Capital's Sherry Cooper.

Change EI system, bank says

One of Canada's biggest banks added its voice to a growing chorus calling on the federal government to change the country's employment insurance system [PDF].

Economists at TD Bank said Thursday Ottawa ought to make it easier for newly unemployed workers to receive benefits and should reverse changes it made to the formula that sets the premiums to be paid by employees and employers.

TD noted that under current rules, anyone applying for employment insurance benefits must have worked for a certain number of hours prior to becoming jobless. But the amount of hours required to qualify varies from region to region in the country, depending on the unemployment rate in that region.

TD economists Derek Burleton and Grant Bishop said this variable entrance requirement (VER) ought to be flattened so that in any region of the country where unemployment is less than 10 per cent, prospective recipients would have to have worked for 560 hours prior to making a claim.

Such a change comes with a price tag of $500 million, the bank said.

In some parts of the country, potential recipients must work as much as 700 hours.

The bank says that as result of the regional differences, only about 80 per cent of those who might be eligible for benefits actually receive them.

The Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives, in a report published Wednesday, has calculated that more than half of those who will lose their jobs this year will not be eligible for EI benefits.

“We urge the government to immediately ease the VER,” the bank said.

If the government standardized the entrance requirement — making it the same in every region of the country — at 420 hours, that would cost about $1 billion, said the bank.

“One important benefit that flows is increased fairness. The truth of the matter is that during an economic downturn, it is no easier to find a job in a region with lower prevailing unemployment than in one with a higher unemployment rate,” the bank said.

[Read the full story]