Last week, Prime Minister Harper announced in the House of Commons that an arbitrator’s report on David Dingwall’s departure as president of the Royal Canadian Mint would be tabled in the House of Commons so long as the third parties mentioned in that report agree to its release. Dingwall himself has agreed to its release. The other two ‘third parties’ are likely John McCallum, the Minister in charge of the Mint at the time of Dingwall’s departure, and then Prime Minister Martin. I spoke to McCallum and, while he had not seen the arbitrator’s report at the time we spoke, he said he could think of no reason why he should object to its release. We have not yet been able to contact Mr. Martin about his opinion on the release of the document.
In any event, Dingwall, pictured left during his appearance last fall in front of a Commons committee, released the following statement today:
Statement by the Hon. David Dingwall,
OTTAWA – The following is a statement by the Hon. David Dingwall, P.C., Q.C. regarding the proposed release of the arbitration ruling awarded by the Hon. George Q. W. Adams, Q.C.
“I have given my consent to the Government to release the award of the Hon. George Adams and I am very pleased that the binding arbitration award by Mr. Adams, a former Justice of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice, will be released to the public by this government. I wish to thank Prime Minister Harper for taking steps to make the entire award public. This award rules that my departure was involuntary and makes a compensatory award.
In the days preceding my resignation from the Royal Canadian Mint, mounting uproar unfolded over my company's lobbying activities, as well as the expenses of the President's Office at the Mint. I immediately assured the Clerk that my expenses were entirely in order, which was subsequently confirmed by an independent audit of PriceWaterhouseCoopers. I also assured the Clerk that my lobbying activities were appropriate and requested that they be reviewed by the Ethics Commissioner. My offer was never withdrawn.
Nevertheless, the Government was clear that it was 'troubled' by the negative publicity surrounding the stories and that all I could rely upon was their silence in face of the criticism. I advised them I felt compelled to resign and no one disagreed with this motivation or the necessity of leaving.
In his careful review of all the facts and evidence, the Hon. George Adams ultimately found that my departure was clearly involuntary – equivalent to a termination or constructive termination without cause.
As the former CEO of the Royal Canadian Mint, I consider it an honour to have led such a fine organization through a strong financial turnaround and I am pleased to see that it is continuing on a successful path into the future in a competitive marketplace.
On a personal note, I am deeply appreciative for the love and support of my wife, children and close friends that have sustained me through this very difficult period.”